2.2Critical reasoning: assumption, strengthen, weaken
The idea
A critical-reasoning question asks what an argument relies on, supports or loses. An assumption is the missing link between evidence and conclusion.
Think of it like this: An argument is a bridge: the premise is one bank, the conclusion the other, and the assumption is the plank in between.
Why it exists
The assumption question appears regularly and has a mechanical solution.
How it works
- Split the argument: premise, conclusion.
- Ask what must also be true for the premise to lead to the conclusion.
- To weaken, give another explanation or break the link; to strengthen, support it.
- Reject answers that are broader than needed.
Worked example: "Geneticists confirm genetic roots, so doctors will eradicate depression."
The bridge: depression must have a genetic basis. The other options claim much more.
Now play with it
- →Do the assumption drill: name the premise and the conclusion first.
- →Weaken one argument by offering another cause.
| Part of an argument | Looks like | Question words |
|---|---|---|
| Premise | evidence or a stated fact | "because", "since", "research shows" |
| Conclusion | what the author wants you to accept | "so", "therefore", "will be able to" |
| Assumption | a hidden link the argument needs | "relies on", "assumes" |
| Strengthen / weaken | support or attack that link | "supports", "undermines" |
Argument: "The new fertiliser raised yields on this farm, so every farm will gain." The unstated assumption is
Check yourself
Which would weaken "Free rides on Sunday doubled ridership, so free rides cause more riding"?
Exam notes (the dense version)
An argument is premise → conclusion. An assumption is the unstated link that must be true for the conclusion to hold (the geneticist argument assumes the illnesses have a genetic basis). To strengthen, support the assumption; to weaken, attack it. Distinguish "must be true" (assumption) from "could be true" (merely consistent).
Previous year questions: Reading & Verbal Reasoning (18)
PYQs are grouped by topic, so this is the full set for Reading & Verbal Reasoning; try the ones that match this subtopic. Open all 18 on the topic page.