← 📖 Reading & Verbal Reasoning
Subtopic 2 of 4

2.2Critical reasoning: assumption, strengthen, weaken

The idea

A critical-reasoning question asks what an argument relies on, supports or loses. An assumption is the missing link between evidence and conclusion.

Think of it like this: An argument is a bridge: the premise is one bank, the conclusion the other, and the assumption is the plank in between.

Why it exists

The assumption question appears regularly and has a mechanical solution.

How it works

  1. Split the argument: premise, conclusion.
  2. Ask what must also be true for the premise to lead to the conclusion.
  3. To weaken, give another explanation or break the link; to strengthen, support it.
  4. Reject answers that are broader than needed.

Worked example: "Geneticists confirm genetic roots, so doctors will eradicate depression."

The bridge: depression must have a genetic basis. The other options claim much more.

Now play with it

  • →Do the assumption drill: name the premise and the conclusion first.
  • →Weaken one argument by offering another cause.
Part of an argumentLooks likeQuestion words
Premiseevidence or a stated fact"because", "since", "research shows"
Conclusionwhat the author wants you to accept"so", "therefore", "will be able to"
Assumptiona hidden link the argument needs"relies on", "assumes"
Strengthen / weakensupport or attack that link"supports", "undermines"

Argument: "The new fertiliser raised yields on this farm, so every farm will gain." The unstated assumption is

Question 1 of 3 · score 0/0

Check yourself

Which would weaken "Free rides on Sunday doubled ridership, so free rides cause more riding"?

Remember: Assumption = the hidden link. Weaken = attack it, strengthen = support it.
Exam notes (the dense version)

An argument is premise → conclusion. An assumption is the unstated link that must be true for the conclusion to hold (the geneticist argument assumes the illnesses have a genetic basis). To strengthen, support the assumption; to weaken, attack it. Distinguish "must be true" (assumption) from "could be true" (merely consistent).

Previous year questions: Reading & Verbal Reasoning (18)

PYQs are grouped by topic, so this is the full set for Reading & Verbal Reasoning; try the ones that match this subtopic. Open all 18 on the topic page.